They remember writing letters and mailing them to the north pole, leaving out milk and cookies, and running downstairs on christmas. Take comfort knowing it doesnt harm your child to imagine the jolly giftbringer. Tell your kid the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, says coulson. Should parents lie to their children about santa claus. They should first ask their child why they think santa might not be real, and encourage them to think about it. It is not uncommon for parents of young children to wonder whether and what they should tell their children about santa claus. How to tell kids about santa explaining the truth about santa to. Last year, he started talking about santa bringing presents and i went along with it. Heres another response to another possible objection. The jolly fat guy is a total sham some adults use to bribe kids into behaving. I have always wondered, should i be the one to tell my kid the truth about santa. Dec 20, 2007 should parents tell their kids the truth or encourage the myth.
Yet growing up while knowing the truth about santa didnt destroy the magic of christmas. Jun 05, 2015 i dont think you should tell your daughter hes not real because i think they should figure it out or just let her believe hes real for a little while longer why she is still little and cute. Parenting winner of the readers favorite international book. He has three grown children, each of whom were curious about santa for a time. Fatherly spoke to coulson at length to find out why he thinks radical truth about. Theres really no one right time to tell kids that theres no santa claus, says. What psychologists really think about you lying to your.
It will work for a while, the child will act good, but as soon as the parent turns their back, they act up. Dec 22, 2009 most of his research has been on the development of childrens curiosity and exploratory behavior. Why you should lie to your kids about santa pbs newshour. In one survey, 84 percent of parents said they had taken. Dec 22, 2016 kathy mckay, a clinical psychologist at the university of new england, australia and coauthor claims. Her parents decision to keep replaying this untruth upsets their daughter to this day. Some parents resist the whole santa thing because peddling make believe will at best when they find out the truth, crush them and, at worst, encourage them to lie. Dec 12, 2017 should we tell children the truth about santa. He was just a story like the ones in books and movies, we said, a bit of fun at christmas. When a child starts asking if santa claus is real, most parents i know. Dont get me wrong, i love christmas it is a truly magical time of. Whether youre writing letters to santa or reading books about reindeer, your childs excitement can. As a christian myself, we tell our kids that santa is a special entertainer who comes for jesus birthday.
The end of the book brings the young reader into the fold of becoming a santa and leaves them excited to be part of this tradition in a new way. You dont have to be a grinch about it just tell them the truth. Should parents tell their children the truth about santa. Dec 18, 2014 when parents tell their kids about santa they know theyre fabricating. Truth be told, i didnt make a big deal about santa with him when he was really little.
Four smart, sweet strategies you know, the talk about how awesome he is open this story with caution, parents. Nov 25, 2016 shops are bursting with toys, mince pies are on the menu and radios are blasting out christmas tunes so its time for another festive favorite. Dec 01, 2016 what should parents tell kids about santa. Pretending santa is real could lead to theological confusion in your children as they get older. The last thing you want is an angry mom calling you up because your kiddo ruined christmas. Should i tell my 7yearold child that santa isnt real. Tell them, guess what, it is us, but we love the magic.
Dec 21, 2016 what psychologists really think about you lying to your kids about santa. From this point of view, white lies like youre the coolest kid in the world or your drawing skills are amazing even though there are 3 scribbles on a sheet have the same potential for disappointment and disillusionment like finding out later the. Like most secular parents in the 1950s and 1960s, there was no issue about whether to tell the truth about santa claus. I tell parents to have conversations in their own families. As much as i believe that you should tell your kid the truth. Parents explain to their kids santa isnt real youtube. Why you shouldnt tell your children that santa claus is. Lying about the easter bunny, santa claus, and the tooth fairy. If you have young children and celebrate this aspect. When i was two years old my parents told me that santa claus didnt exist. Truth about santa claus is an irresistible instant classic no parent should be without.
Most parents do not worry very much that encouraging the santa myth is harmful or that eventually spilling the beans will make. If you have young children and celebrate this aspect of christmas, you need this book at some point. Should parents tell lies like santa and the easter bunny to. Trying to keep other kids from finding out the truth can cause a. Nicholas was born to christian parents who left him an inheritance when they died, which he distributed to. Historically the story of santa is actually about unconditional love. Knowing when to tell children that santa is not real is one of the most common problems parents have to face.
Should parents tell lies like santa and the easter bunny. My parents went along with the program, telling us the story about santa claus traveling around the world delivering presents to good boys and girls. Family expert says parents should let kids beliefs about santa develop naturally dec, 2012 child development expert says the magic of santa claus is no lie. Should parents tell their kids the truth or encourage the myth. Why you shouldnt tell your children that santa claus is real. He gave gifts to kids, so parents just continue on the tradition. Should parents tell their children the truth about santa claus.
Its that time of year where some parents find themselves in the heartbreaking position of telling their kids theres no such thing as santa. The best way to tell your kids the truth about santa. A psychotherapist on when to tell your child the truth about santa. Make them promise to tell their friends to ask their own parents if they have questions about santa. Even though i wasnt sure how i felt about it, i felt kind of bad about killing the joy for him before he got the chance to really experience it. Dec 12, 2018 the children should know that theyre made up, and they should know why parents tell children madeup stories. So how soon should you tell your kids the truth about santa. Dec 15, 2017 dr coulson believes parents need to be careful about how they tell the truth about santa.
Even worse, i, like parents across america, have turned the benevolentish construct into a sort of orwellian overlord, a man with lists and. Santa claus remains a controversial figure among many scientists and parents. Then they should explain the origins of santa, before finally admitting the truth. So i guess were just not supposed to tell our children any stories, let them watch any movies or read. He said yes and i said would you like to learn the trick to the magic and showed. She says that its likely at some point your kids will ask about santa or theyll get to an age where they should know the truth.
Dec 06, 2016 how to tell your kids the truth about santa claus leave a comment. Written from a christian perspective, this story, when read to a child, will enable any parent to. In his book, johnson, whose expertise is in formal logic, lays out an ethical argument against indoctrinating. Justin coulson thinks that parents are overcomplicating the whole thing. The truth about santa claus is the first in a series entitled when your child is ready to hear. What psychologists really think about you lying to your kids. How to tell your kids the truth about santa claus globalnews. Dec 05, 2019 children react differently to hearing the news about santa. As parents, we know that santa doesnt exist, but does that mean sharing this myth with our children is really lying.
And some parents tell kids that christmas is all about giving, and now that they know the truth about santa, their job is to become santa to someone else this makes giving part of their future. Heres how to tell your kids that santa claus is real. Although some might say that children will actually try to behave if you tell them santa is always watching, it really is just as effective when a parents says that they want a child to be good. When should you tell your child the truth about santa. David kyle johnson is the author of the 2015 book the myths that stole. Luckily, the majority of kids in class do still believe, so they outnumber the. Apr, 2017 why we should tell children the truth about santa. Parents should tell their children the truth about santa claus when their children signal they are ready to hear it. Hes still been excitedly talking about santa bringing him books like last year. Dec 03, 2016 should you tell your kids the truth about santa. Why its ok for kids to believe in santa claus psychology today.
The last thing you want is an angry mom calling you up because. These books assist parents in the difficult task of answering lifes tough questions. Dec 07, 2016 image via shutterstock viral post gives parents the perfect way to tell kids the truth about santa. Getty every year at christmas, parents everywhere convince their little ones that if they behave themselves for the next couple of weeks, a. Dec 03, 2018 of course, the clearest result of being caught lying, whether its a small lie or a big one, is the disappointment, the deception. And we did the same thing with our own kids when they were young. Only a grinch would enjoy breaking the news about the santa lie to a. Heres an idea for breaking the santa news without breaking. Dec 21, 2016 santa parents explain to their kids santa isnt real cut. Give it context, and remind your child that other parents might not tell their kids so its just a secret for you to share for now. So, how much thought should a parent put into the question of telling kids about santa. Although santa claus is a mythical figure, his creation is based in part on a great christian man named saint nicholas of myra, who lived in the 4th century. Its a question parents often ask me in my therapy office. Its a good thing, i think, to tell children madeup stories.
In truth perpetuating the santa myth is not likely to hurt. How to tell kids about santa explaining the truth about. Should parents tell their kids the truth about santa claus. Fatherly spoke to coulson at length to find out why he thinks radical truth about the myth of santa claus is the best for kids. They remember writing letters and mailing them to the north pole, leaving out milk and cookies, and running downstairs on christmas morning to see what santa had left for them under the tree. When we tell them the santa claus lie, we betray that trust. My children think its odd that other parents pretend santa is real there wasnt an occasion when we had to sit our boys down and explain that santa was not real. The book focuses on the wonderful, giving and generous spirit of christmas addressing how santa came to be and why parents continue the tradition.
This beautiful, feelgood picture book helps parents with the inevitable question is santa real. Questions such as who the parents, school, friends, etc. Do yourself and your kids a favour and drop the santa charade, writes ben pobjie. Dec 18, 2014 the young woman i just mentioned talked about how upset she was with her parents when she discovered that this elaborate story wasnt true. What should christians tell their children about santa claus.
For some parents, pushing your children to believe in santa may feel like lying. My 9yearold daughter seemed proud to have matured into this grownup secret she could keep from her younger siblings. Jul 19, 20 the big secret, the whole and honest truth about santa claus is an irresistible instant classic no parent should be without. There is a nationwide trend of parents rushing to tell their little children that there is no santa. Struggling over whether or not to tell the story of santa to your child. Miraculously, this book tells the real truth about santa claus in a way that makes it even more joyous and beautiful. The santa myth is such an involved lie, such a longlasting one, between parents and children, that if a relationship is vulnerable, this may be the final straw.
For many people, santa is a cherished part of their holiday traditions. Great book to let your kids know the truth about father christmas without them. Parents are being urged to reconsider, in the lead up to christmas, what. For those who have received this tradition and doubt the propriety of. Most people i tell this to, let out a long sighing, ohhhh. Written from a christian perspective, this story, when read to a child, will enable any parent to confidently explain the true meaning of christmas. Miraculously, this book tells the real truth about santa claus in a way that. He was just a story like the ones in books and movies, we said, a bit of fun at.
265 737 1202 489 1360 1489 61 316 1619 1408 1638 1495 820 1082 298 826 263 400 915 1316 570 1675 1374 1136 1617 1440 390 1507 923 365 1104 1289 333 524 1119 667 391 1217